All resources
9 min read·Updated

How to Conduct a Workplace Investigation in Australia

A step-by-step guide for HR professionals and investigators covering scope, evidence gathering, procedural fairness, and findings, tailored for Australian workplaces.

Quick answer

To conduct a workplace investigation in Australia: set a clear scope, appoint an independent investigator, secure the evidence, interview the complainant, witnesses and then the respondent, give the respondent the substance of every allegation and a genuine chance to respond, then make findings on the balance of probabilities and report them to a separate decision-maker. Courts and the Fair Work Commission look at the fairness of that process as closely as the outcome.

Why a structured process matters

A workplace investigation that lacks a clear, documented process exposes your organisation to unfair dismissal claims, adverse action applications, and reputational damage. Australian courts and tribunals scrutinise process as much as outcome. A well-founded decision made through a flawed process can still be overturned.

The Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) requires employers to follow a fair procedure before taking disciplinary action. That means the respondent must know the allegation against them, have a genuine opportunity to respond, and receive a decision based on the evidence, not a predetermined outcome.

Step 1: Scope the investigation

Before you interview a single witness, define what you are and are not investigating. Scope creep is one of the most common causes of delays and cost blowouts. Document:

  • The specific allegations or conduct in question
  • The relevant policies or obligations allegedly breached
  • Who will be investigated (respondent) and who may have witnessed the conduct
  • The time period under scrutiny
  • Any related matters that should be dealt with separately

A narrow, clear scope keeps the investigation defensible and protects you from allegations that the process was a fishing expedition.

Step 2: Appoint an appropriate investigator

The investigator must be independent, ideally with no prior involvement in the complaint or the relationship between the parties. In smaller organisations this may mean appointing an external investigator. The investigator should have:

  • Sufficient seniority or authority to make findings
  • No conflict of interest (actual or perceived)
  • Competence in interviewing and evidence evaluation

Where the allegations involve potential criminal conduct, consider whether to involve law enforcement before proceeding with an internal investigation.

Step 3: Notify the respondent and secure evidence

Notify the respondent in writing that an investigation is underway. You do not need to provide full details at this stage, as doing so may give them an opportunity to destroy evidence, but they should know an investigation is occurring. At the same time:

  • Preserve email and system logs (work with IT)
  • Secure physical evidence (CCTV footage, access records, documents)
  • Consider whether a stand-down or temporary redeployment is appropriate pending the investigation

Step 4: Conduct witness interviews

Interview the complainant first, then independent witnesses, then the respondent. For each interview:

  • Record the date, time, location, and attendees
  • Inform the interviewee of the purpose of the interview and their confidentiality obligations
  • Use open questions and avoid leading the witness
  • Take contemporaneous notes and have the witness sign them where possible

The respondent must be given the substance of the allegations against them and a genuine opportunity to respond before any findings are made. Provide them with a written summary of allegations and allow a reasonable time to prepare a response.

Step 5: Evaluate the evidence and make findings

The standard of proof in a workplace investigation is the balance of probabilities, meaning more likely than not. Weigh the evidence by considering the credibility of witnesses, corroborating evidence, and any inherent implausibility.

The more serious the allegation and its consequences, the stronger the evidence you need before you are reasonably satisfied it happened. This is the Briginshaw principle (from Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336). It does not create a higher standard of proof, but a finding of serious misconduct such as sexual harassment, fraud or violence should not rest on thin or inexact evidence.

Document your reasoning. A finding that says "we prefer the complainant's account because X, Y, and Z" is far more defensible than one that simply states "the allegation is substantiated". Be specific about which allegations are substantiated, partially substantiated, or not substantiated.

Case360 keeps every step documented automatically.

Audit trail, evidence storage, task tracking, and AI Fact Find, built for Australian investigators.

Start free trial

Step 6: Deliver findings and recommendations

Produce a written investigation report addressed to the decision-maker (who may not be the investigator). The report should:

  • Summarise the allegations and process
  • Set out the evidence considered
  • Make findings on each allegation

Whether the report includes recommendations depends on the nature of the engagement. An internal investigator, such as an HR manager or in-house counsel, will often include recommendations for remedial action, such as training, policy changes, or referral to management for a disciplinary decision. An independent external investigator, however, should generally confine their report to findings of fact and leave all remedial and disciplinary recommendations to the organisation. Including recommendations can compromise the appearance of independence and expose the investigator to criticism if the recommendations are not followed.

The decision-maker then considers the findings and determines the appropriate response. Keeping the investigator and decision-maker roles separate is best practice, as it protects the organisation if the decision is later challenged.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Predetermined outcome: Starting with a conclusion and working backwards destroys credibility
  • No right of response: The respondent must be given particulars and a chance to reply
  • Inadequate documentation: If it isn't written down, it didn't happen
  • Losing confidentiality: Gossip during an investigation can give rise to defamation claims
  • Unreasonable delay: Prolonged investigations can constitute procedural unfairness

Frequently asked questions

Who should conduct a workplace investigation?

Someone independent of the complaint and the people involved, with the skills to interview and weigh evidence. Smaller organisations, or matters involving senior staff, often need an external workplace investigator.

What standard of proof applies in a workplace investigation?

The balance of probabilities: more likely than not. Under the Briginshaw principle, more serious allegations need stronger evidence before you can be reasonably satisfied they occurred.

Does the respondent have to be told the allegations?

Yes. Procedural fairness requires the respondent to be given the substance of each allegation and a genuine opportunity to respond before any findings are made.

Can an employee have a support person in an investigation interview?

It is good practice to allow one. If the matter leads to dismissal, the Fair Work Act treats an unreasonable refusal to allow a support person at related discussions as a factor in whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable.

How long should a workplace investigation take?

As long as needed to be thorough, but no longer. Simple matters can take a few weeks and complex ones longer. Keep the parties informed, because unexplained delay can itself be unfair.

Related on Case360

This guide is general information for Australian workplaces, not legal advice. Laws differ between jurisdictions and change over time, so get advice on your specific matter.

    How to Conduct a Workplace Investigation in Australia | Case360